Intro: Health dept grants a Rs 70 lakhs a year single tender contract to Ecoclean to wash GMC’s laundry. Documents reveal that order was passed, by health department “although being a single tender”
- Rs 7 crores in 10 years or Rs 70 lakhs annually. This is how much you will pay for GMCs laundry to be cleaned by a single company
- Compare this to the total amount spent on housekeeping and cleaning, which is a mere 9.6 lakhs a year
TEAM THE GOA SPOTLIGHT
PANJIM: Take a deep breath to get some clean facts about GMC’s dirty linen. They will now be washed at a cost of Rs 70 lakhs a year or Rs 7 crores for ten years. All of this money (your money) will be paid to , apparently a favorite company of Health Minister Vishwajit Rane
The powers in the GMCH, obviously under the instructions of the Health minister, have favoured M/s Ecoclean System and Solutions by giving it the work of In-House laundry services at a whopping annual cost of Rs 70 lakhs. This is in all likelihood, higher than the cost of buying bed sheets and bed linen for the Goa Medical college and hospital
Trupti B Manerkar, Under Secretary (Health) while issuing the Administrative Order has admitted the fallacy of the tender. Interestingly, the order signed by Manerkar has mentioned that M/S Ecoclean System and Solutions are given a tender “although being a Single Tender.”
The words “although being a single tender” can clearly be interpreted to mean that this order was passed inspite of there being just one company which pitched for a tender, which clearly should have been an open tender for laundry services. The abnormality of the order is admitted in the draft of the order itself
Earlier the same laundry was run by the GMC with the existing staff with the machinery purchased 15 years back.
The State government while arriving at a figure of Rs 70,00,000 a year annually did not do any market survey. Legislative Assembly Question 20 tabled by MLA Nilesh Cabral asked ‘Whether any market survey was done before preparing the estimate for laundry tender to ascertain market price. The reply tables stated ‘No. However institutional assessment was done based on the expenditure carried out in the previous years’.
Goa needs to know what the jargon ‘institutional assessment’ is. There is no possibility of any “assessment” which points to a Rs 70 lakhs a year or a Rs 6 lakhs a month cost for washing
And we ask what stopped the government from upgrading the existing machinery and employing more staff to man the laundry.
EcoClean is Junior Rane’s favourite
The company seems to be favourite of Junior Rane. EcoClean Systems and Solutions have also been given the contract of housekeeping and cleaning services at GMCH. The same company which was paid Rs 2.71 crore for the year 2016 had its bill raised to Rs 3.94 crore for the year 2017 leaving scope for suspicion.
For housekeeping and cleaning, the company charged Rs 21 lakh in the month of December 2016 but its bill went up to Rs 73 lakh for December 2017. The company which was charging around 21 lakh to 23 lakh monthly in the year 2016 suddenly upped its bill to Rs 78 lakh for the month of November 2017.
ALSO NOTE: (Another firm M/S Veejay Facilities Management Pvt Ltd which has been given contract to look after the housekeeping and cleaning services in the facilities (excluding GMCH) also saw major rise in its bill for the year 2017.
The company which was paid Rs 38.99 lakh for the year 2016 had its bill shooting up to Rs 88.37 lakh for the year 2017. This exponential growth in the Bill is unjustified and needs to be investigated. The same firm had charged Rs28.85 lakh for the year 2015.
The decision to award the single tender for laundry services to EcoClean Systems and Solutions is an apparent violation of the guidelines of Competition Commission of India which has discouraged single bids in order to curb the corruption in the system.
But while in case of the Goa Medical College, Administrative approval and expenditure sanction of the government was given for awarding the work of installation and operation of In-House laundry services for Goa Medical College to M/S Ecoclean systems and solutions at the rate of Rs 11.40 per piece.
Moreover, the contract signed with the company is for ten years, which has eradicated any possibility of retendering the work till the year 2028.
What’s interesting is that the company is entirely Goa based and does not have the experience of working on major contracts. Health Minsiter Vishwajit Rane in his written reply has claimed that the company’s previous experience was undertaking the laundry service with effect from 2011 at Sou. Sushila Danchand Ghodawat Charitable Trust’s Group of Institutions.
This is the only experience the Panjim headquartered company has got under its belt, but still managed to win such a huge contract worth Rs 7 crores for ten years at a stretch
Also as a part of the contract, he will have the prerogative of taking over the functional laundry. The functional laundry equipments existing in the laundry section are handed over to the firm. The machines will be repaired; renovated and new machines will be replaced by the contractor at his own cost.
The issue had figured during the recently held monsoon session of the House during which Curchorem MLA Nilesh Cabral had tabled the question about the tender.
This is not the last you will hear of the story. But there will rarely be a more visually correct example of money going down the drain. And the Health Minister who only wished to wash GMC’s dirty linen, may find his proverbial dirty linen hung out to dry in public if this scam is inquired into.
A govt run from hospitals, but surviving all right
Rupesh Samant/ Team Spotlight
GOA: As we are getting ready to wind up with the year 2018, Goa will remember these 365 days as the one calendar year without the State getting Manohar Parrikar touch. The Chief Minister has been ailing, seriously, since February this year, slowing down the pace of governance in this BJP and alliance parties ruled State.
The year was marked with the politicking of alliance partners and opposition Congress party. While Congress has been trying to create a wedge in the alliance, BJP’s partners have remained firm despite passing out from the honeymoon period.
Since the year 1994, when Parrikar emerged on State’s political scene, this was the first time that we saw him “being there but not there” due to his health conditions.
Here we bring to you a crisp and quick round up of the political year in Goa that we are readying to say good bye.
Alliance kept government on notice
Maharashtrawadi Gomantak Party led other alliance partners in its impatient behaviour during the year. MGP President Dipak Dhavalikar gave several deadlines to the State government warning of a stringent action but none of their demands were fulfilled. MGP’s primary demand was to hand over the Chief Minister’s responsibilities to Sudin Dhavalikar owing to the ill-health of Parrikar. Dhavalikar was supporting his elder brother as he the senior most amongst others in the cabinet.
Goa Forward Party’s strategic moves is the main reason why Dhavalikar despite coming close to the chair could not get it. The events on the budget day in February signified how BJP and its CM Parrikar were decisive on maintaining a distance between Dhavalikar and CM’s post. On the budget day, Parrikar who was admitted in Lilavati Hospital of Mumbai rushed to present the budget statement on the floor of the House.
Since February till December 15, the MGP has been giving deadlines, the recent one being related to resumption of mining activity. But they never dared to walk out.
GFP also showed their impatience, during certain time, over the slowing down of the Administration. GFP President Vijai Sardesai was occasionally vocal on the issue but was quick enough to add in the same breath that people “needed to understand that CM is unwell.”
Vijai Sardesai has been one of the most loyal politicians to BJP even compared to their own MLAs, something which has earned him the respect if the
Independents like Rohan Khaunte and Prasad Gaonkar too raised the flags of rebellion, but not with much seriousness. Gaonkar resigned as Chairman of Goa Forest Development Corporation, but post that, he had made no attempts to redress his grievances.
Rumblings within BJP
BJP was at its worst during the year with internal fighting becoming order of the day. Michael Lobo and Francis D’Souza were furious at the party organization on various occasions for different reasons. D’Souza was sacked from the cabinet along with Pandurang Madkaikar. D’Souza minced no words in criticizing the BJP.
Another big ticket fight was between a former Chief Minister and state party president Laxmikant Parsekar and current state president Vinay Tendulkar. Parsekar was upset after the Congress MLA from his constituency Mandrem, (against whom he lost) Dayanand Sopte was inducted in the BJP and would be given a BP ticket to contest the by-elections, as a result of his resignation
Similar was reaction from former Industries minister Mahadev Naik when Subhash Shirodkar became a BJP leader in Shiroda
By the end of year, BJP had their RSS troubleshooter General Secretary Satish Dhond back in Goa. After his arrival some of BKJP’s defeated leaders like Dilip Parulekar, Damodar Naik, Kiran Kandolkar, Rajan Naik has once against started climbing up the stairs of Navelcar Arcade, where the Goa BJP’s headquarters are located in Panjim
Mining crisis dented BJP’s image
The crisis hovering on the Iron Ore mining industry was one of the major highlights of the year. The Supreme Court delivered a judgment on February 7 quashing 88 mining leases. The order came into force from midnight of March 15.
The closure is estimated to have affected two lakh mining dependents. But those who are impacted in a big way are around 20,000 people. BJP could not salvage the industry from crisis. In the absence of CM Parrikar, none from the party or the government were able to provide the solution. The party agreed to suggestions of Goa Mining People’s Front to amend the Mining Law in the Parliament giving a new lease of life to mining till 2037.
Auctioning or forming State run Corporation were two other ways that were being thought about to restart mining. But those solutions also stand discarded, at least till now.
The shadow of mining crisis, will hover over the next elections, as the BJP had won majority seats in the iron ore rich belt in the year 2012 and retained their monopoly till 2017.
Major decisions remained on hold in the absence of CM
Major decisions like Tourism Master plan (final), the Casino Policy (final) and others being kept on hold as CM remained hospitalized for most of the year. Tourism Policy is yet to see the light of the day. So also, the off shore casinos are getting extensions after extensions to stay put at River Mandovi, causing angst amongst the NGOs and anti-gambling lobbies.
The State had assured to create an Entertainment Zone near proposed Mopa Airport so that they can be shifted on land. The policy is yet to take shape. There is no word coming from the State government on this issue.
TCP Amendment and the Opposition
TCP Minister Vijai Sardesai faced a lot of opposition during the year. First it was the formation of Greater Panaji Planning and Development Authority and later amendment to the TCP Act, the minister continues to be on the target of NGOs and civil society activists. Ironically the minister, responding to the people had actually scrapped most of the panchayat areas, hitherto included under the Greater Panjim PDA
But when it came to case-to-case basis conversion of land from Orchard to Settlement, he faced flak. The minister has said that the case to case basis was to help those people whose lands were suddenly transported into orchard from settlement during drafting of RP 2021. As the process of conversion is going on, the opposition seems to be dying down. He explained that the move was to see that those who made investments as per the land categorization prevalent then and then suffered as the categorization changed.
IT Park at Chimbel sparked Rohan versus Rudolf war
IT Minister Rohan Khaunte’s ambitious plan to have Information Technology and ITES park at Chimbel caused an altercation with former minister Victoria Fernandes and her son Rudolf.
Khaunte went on the record to abuse Rudolf as “goonda” and “extortionist” while latter continued shooting from the shoulders of social activists and locals from Chimbel.
The opposition for IT Park has continued though the State government has already appointed a consultant for the project. The year 2019 will see more events and clashes related to the IT park.
Looking at 2019, the BJP led government has to take decision making forward and in quick time especially when it comes to finances, jobs, tourism and land issues while going on working on the ongoing issues like garbage disposal and errant taxi drivers. Most importantly, Goa needs to emerge as a decision making, and not a decision dragging state.
Forensic head of GMC faces serious charges for wrong disposal of Januz Gonsalves’ body
CCP officials may not face charges since they weren’t tasked with identifying bodies
-Aldona boy Januz Gonsalves’ dead body was disposed off with a set of unclaimed bodies by a mistake
-GMC morgue officials made this tragic and shocking goof up
-Charges of criminal neglect among others likely tp be slapped on former head of Forensics, Dr E J Rodrigues, junior technician Machindranath Jalmi and post mortem attendant Prakash Narvekar,
GOA (PANJIM) There is no replacement to the loss of a loved one and Januz Gonsalves’ family would understand better than most. All hopes that the bereaved family would find justice are pinned on the investigation that is in final stages.
But there’s already a surprise in store. The Crime Branch may not press charges who were asked to dispose off three unclaimed bodies and they picked Januz’ body by “mistake” and disposed off it even before his family members arrived to claim it. Corporation of the City of Panaji (CCP) staff may be given relief since they were not tasked with identifying bodies before their disposal. “Identification of the bodies lying in the GMC morgue is the responsibility of the hospital authorities and not the CCP. The forensic team handed over the body to the CCP staff without verification and therefore the hospital authorities will face the charges of criminal negligence,” a government official said wishing anonymity.
But serious charges against suspended Forensic Head of the Goa Medical College Dr E J Rodrigues, junior technician Machindranath Jalmi and post mortem attendant Prakash Narvekar, are in store
Gross human error and malfunctioning of the morgue cabinets led to the forensic department hand over wrong body to the CCP, which ultimately deprived Januz’s family give him a decent burial.
The CB claims to have gathered clinching evidence against the errant GMC officials.The five-year-old state-of-the-art mortuary is infamous for repeated breakdowns. The blunder in the case of Januz was a result of this same technical error.
The blunder also gave rise to wild speculations on the possibility of organ harvesting. Whether or not the accused were anywhere involved in organ trafficking is expected to be covered in the investigation, although, highly placed sources have said there is no proof so far.
The GMC has seconded the findings of the Crime Branch on the organ trafficking angle with Dean Dr Pradeep Naik denying any such illegal trade in the hospital. “There is no organ trafficking activity in the hospital,” he told this reporter.
The sinister leadership in the GMC morgue affairs however continues to haunt the hospital. While immediate suspension was one way of rectifying the blunder, the GMC has taken a step further and terminated the extension to the then head of forensics GMC, Dr Edmundo J Rodrigues, The Dean said that the Forensic HoD, who was on an extension till mid-2019, not associated with the hospital anymore. “His extension of one year, from mid-2018 to mid-2019 is terminated,” Dr Naik said.
Dr Edmundo had the responsibility for granting approval for handing over the bodies for disposal. The Crime Branch is investigating whether the bodies are actually checked before handing them over to the CCP for disposal.
The Crime Branch is also investigating the overwriting and scribbling on the department’s register that raised suspicion over the exchange of dead bodies in the cabinets. The investigation team has found that while the entry timing of other bodies was made in blue ball pen, entry in one column of an unclaimed body was in red pen. The age in another column is also re-written indicating foul play. The Superintendant of Police of the Crime Branch, Kartik Kashyap, while refusing to discuss the details, has only stated that the handwriting has been sent for forensic examination. “The report is awaited, otherwise the probe is complete. Once the report arrives and we get government sanction to charge-sheet the government servants, we will file a charge-sheet. It should be done in about two months,” he said.
Each rape of a tourist is a new nail in Goa’s tourism coffin
GOA (CANACONA) The arrest of the supposed rapist of the 48 year old British woman in Canacona within a day, might give the Goa police some breathing space, as criticism mounts over the safety of foreign tourists in Goa. However, the rape in Canacona, where such violent incidents have happened before is yet another nail in the coffin of Goa’s tourism.
In the latest case of the 48 year old British woman, the Margao police have picked up a robber on the run who was arrested in Pernem after stealing about Rs 31 lakhs, and found that he had the ATM card of the British woman who was raped. This was a sheer stroke of luck and perhaps luck is all that the Goa police needs and has, to get out of the spiral of unsolved rape and murder cases of foreign tourists.
What has made Goa unsafe in the perception of foreign tourists, tour operators and sections of the government- especially in Britain- is that many criminals roam free and escape the arm of the law. To a large extent this is true.
The accused in the latest Canacona rape case was identified as Ramchandran Y ( 31) from Thanjavur in Tamil Nadu. Similarly, in other cases, like the gang rape of a Goan woman in Betalbatim, the perpetrators were from outside Goa. Goa is increasingly becoming a hunting ground for rapists from other states, whose acts deliver a blow to the prospects of Goa as a safe destination for tourists and even locals.
The latest Canacona rape in December follows an open letter written In November 2018, by Sanna Pirhonen Cutter and Minna Pirhonen aunt and mother of the deceased Finnisbh tourist Felix Dahl, to the Goa government on behalf of families who have lost their loved ones, in Goa, each of whom have died under mysterious circumstances
In 2015, Dahl was found dead on the streets of Agonda.
The letter reported by most of the local dailies of Goa, was written in the backdrop of the draft tourism policy of Goa released around that time. The letter sated “As usual, the most important aspect has been left out completely, which is the tourist itself. Tourists make the tourism in Goa. Because today there is no safety, law or order to protect the tourists, they choose a safer destination at the moment. Due to the unsolved murders and death cases, Goa today seems a very risky and dangerous destination”
The letter went on to add “The unsolved murders should be investigated rapidly to have the guilty Goans or any other nationals prosecuted and convicted. Crimes happen elsewhere too, but there is an attempt to catch the killers, but that is not the case in Goa…When the local authorities clean the destinations from the dangerous elements, they can be recommended to tourists as safe destinations. Tourists should be warned about those localities where unsolved crimes still exists.
The cases are piling up. And when you have murders and/ or rapes of international tourists annually, it’s enough to scare even the most ardent Goa loving foreign tourist.
Importantly, the number of rapes and murders/ mysterious deaths of foreign tourists in Goa’s southern most taluka, Canacona is something that both the foreign press and families of victims are contending with and there is ring of solidarity around them.
And this group, for all the right reasons, continuously raise red flags in social media and elsewhere, not letting the focus on these cases as well as the level of policing and investigation in new cases, to cease.
Danielle McLaughlin was killed in March 2017 in Canacona, the same village where the latest gruesome rape happened. But here the trial is going on in court and the alleged killer has been identified.
Going back to Dahl’s death, In 2015, Finnish student Felix Dahl, was found killed, in suspicious circumstances and his body was found in Patnem in Canacona with skull fractures and brain haemorrhage. In 2016 the Goa police closed the case which was then handed over to the CBI on the orders of the High Court.
And the High Court’s observations about the shoddy investigation, is a clear indictment of not this case alone but a pattern of the manner in which these cases are dealt with. Commenting on the nature of police investigations in the case filed to get the Felix Dahl investigations done by a seemingly more competent agency, the bench of Justices Prithviraj K Chavan and NM Jamdar observed “In the entire investigation papers, there is no indication at all that angle of homicide is considered. Why not is the moot question,” it said.
The bench further noted, “The skull is one of the hardest bone in the human body. For the skull to have five life-threatening fractures with haemorrhage, it was likely to be a result of a violent force. What we find surprising is that this theory was not even considered as possible”.
But there was another line in the observation which was the most damning because here the bench indicated that there was actually a motive behind the police steering away from the homicide angle and it wasn’t just professional incompetence, mentioning that the police “chose” to avoid investigating this as a murder case. It stated “The local police have CHOSEN to steer the investigation clear of the angle of homicide, even though it was one of the strong hypothesis,”
And in North Goa, we woke up to the death of Denyse Sweeney in 2012, after her visit to a night club a case still mired in mystery. And of course, the drowning ( a case of potential murder though the judgment in the trial court did not conclude as such) of British teenager Scarlett Keeling, was one of the most covered and watched cases in the world, through the first two years since Scarlett died in 2008.
The latest rape of a British tourist in the week leading up to Christmas has once again brought Goa back in the national and international media glare as an unsafe tourism destination, and we are entering the high tourist season.
There have been many such cases that have seen no closure. It could, in the long run, lead to a closure of the tourism industry in Goa.